Mandla Ncikazi returns to Golden Arrows

Five games without a win is a stark line to inherit, but Mandla Ncikazi has never been one for soft landings. Unveiled as Golden Arrows head coach hours after Orlando Pirates confirmed his departure, the long‑serving tactician returns to Abafana Bes’thende with history on his side and a repair job squarely in front of him.

Pirates chairman Dr Irvin Khoza sent him off with the kind of public blessing that hints at the regard in which he’s held. “Mandla leaves with our gratitude and our blessing,” Khoza said, noting that “his contribution to Orlando Pirates has been evident throughout his time with us. We respect his wish.” That wish is clear enough: a return to the seat where he guided Arrows to fourth in 2020/21, this time to halt a skid and transplant lessons from a spell that included helping steer Pirates to a CAF Confederation Cup final.

The return and the five-game knot he must untie

Arrows’ season began with promise. They were unbeaten in their first six matches, a start that included MTN8 wins over Kaizer Chiefs and Mamelodi Sundowns. But momentum has bled away: the club were five games without a win when Pitso Dladla was dismissed, despite Dladla having only two losses to his name.

That decision opened the door for a familiar figure. Abafana Bes’thende announced Ncikazi’s return on Thursday, a move grounded in precedent as much as need. He was the architect of that 2020/21 fourth‑place finish before departing for Pirates, and he steps back into a dressing room that has proved it can hit a high level early in a campaign, even if the last five outings have undercut that belief.

There is no shortcut to turning a run like this. The brief is straightforward: steady results, rediscover the edge that delivered those two MTN8 scalps, and make the team’s early resilience more durable. Without plunging into grand tactical promises, Arrows need a reset — and Ncikazi is being asked to supply it quickly.

A Pirates apprenticeship with continental stakes

Ncikazi’s time at Orlando Pirates began in June 2021, and it immediately put him under bright lights. In 2021/22 he co‑coached alongside Fadlu Davids, and that campaign’s continental run remains a defining line on his CV: Pirates reached the CAF Confederation Cup final, losing to RS Berkane on penalties. The pressure of that run, and the navigation of two‑man leadership at a club of Pirates’ size, has shaped perceptions of Ncikazi as steady, adaptable and unflustered by scale.

When Davids left, Ncikazi didn’t. He stayed and worked as an assistant to Jose Riveiro and, later, Abdeslam Ouaddou. Through those transitions Pirates piled up silverware. As Khoza put it, “his contribution to Orlando Pirates has been evident throughout his time with us,” and the record speaks for the era: during his Mayfair stint the club won four successive MTN8 titles, two Nedbank Cups, the Carling Knockout, the Carling Black Label Cup and the Betway Premiership title.

The distinction matters: those trophies belong to the club, and the head coach’s line changed. But the constant on the staff list was Ncikazi. He was part of a group that absorbed change without losing momentum, a useful credential now that he inherits a team that has run hot and cold within the span of a few weeks.

A fourth-place memory in Durban, and why it still resonates

Ncikazi does not arrive as a stranger. His previous Arrows tenure delivered a fourth‑place finish in the 2020/21 season, a high‑water mark that set the tone for what the club can be when structure, clarity and buy‑in align. That achievement is the anchor for this return — a reference point for supporters and players who remember the standard that was set.

It also reframes expectations. This is not a blank‑slate appointment at a crisis club; Arrows have already shown this season they can compete with, and beat, heavyweights in knockout football. The task is to turn an encouraging opening into something sustainable, the way that 2020/21 campaign became a coherent whole under his guidance.

Frictions and farewells at Mayfair, managed on the way out

Ncikazi’s exit from Pirates arrives after days in which the rumour mill whirred. There had been talk of a rift between Abdeslam Ouaddou and Ncikazi, but the head coach dismissed those suggestions earlier on Thursday. Whatever the internal dynamics, the official line from Pirates is simple: Ncikazi requested to leave to pursue a head‑coach role with another PSL club — Golden Arrows.

Pirates confirmed his exit and Arrows announced his return on Thursday. Khoza’s words set the tone. “We respect his wish,” he said, and with that Ncikazi heads for a dugout where the responsibility is fully his again, the accountability clearer, and the goals immediate.

The detail

Inside the Pirates bench model, 2021–2026

The line through Ncikazi’s Pirates tenure is continuity amid changing leadership structures. He arrived in June 2021 and, in 2021/22, co‑coached the first team with Fadlu Davids — a rare arrangement in South Africa’s top flight that demands clearly defined in‑game responsibilities and off‑field cohesion. That season culminated in a CAF Confederation Cup final against RS Berkane, settled on penalties, the kind of high‑stakes endpoint that tests a staff’s communication under stress. When the co‑coaching period ended with Davids’ departure, Ncikazi recalibrated as an assistant under Jose Riveiro and later Abdeslam Ouaddou.

Those transitions coincided with a sustained surge in trophies at Mayfair: across this period Pirates won four straight MTN8 titles, two Nedbank Cups, the Carling Knockout, the Carling Black Label Cup and the Betway Premiership title. The attribution belongs to a collective, but the through‑line is instructive for Arrows. Ncikazi has spent five years operating within elite performance environments where the head coach changed but the standards didn’t, and he leaves with the chairman’s public endorsement ringing in his ears. For a team now five without a win after an unbeaten six‑match start, that embedded sense of stability is precisely what he is being hired to recreate.

The job description at Arrows, right now

Strip away the noise and the brief is grounded in three realities set out this week. One: Arrows began their season solidly and were unbeaten in six. Two: those results included MTN8 wins over Kaizer Chiefs and Mamelodi Sundowns — proof of ceiling. Three: the club are on a five‑match run without a win, which cost Pitso Dladla his job even though he only lost two games.

Ncikazi inherits that contradiction: a squad capable of upsetting giants but unable, of late, to close games out in their favour. He is not walking into a rebuild; he is walking into a correction. The priority is to translate the knockout‑game precision that saw off Chiefs and Sundowns into week‑to‑week work, and to do it quickly enough that the season’s early promise is not consigned to a footnote.

The club context has been fluid. Dladla himself had stepped in after Manqoba Mngqithi — who left to coach Young Africans SC in Tanzania — and held the line through six unbeaten matches. But patience thins quickly when the results turn. Ncikazi’s appointment is both a nod to institutional memory and a bet that a familiar hand can steady a listing course.

What will count as success in the second act

There are two obvious markers. The first is immediate: snap the five‑game run without a win and rebuild momentum. That is the floor. The second is medium‑term: build towards a league campaign that echoes his own 2020/21 benchmark of a fourth‑place finish, even if the journey there will differ and the obstacles will be new.

There is also perception to manage. Ncikazi leaves a club where, as Pirates confirmed, he requested an exit to return to a head‑coach role. That means he owns the outcomes now — the upside of autonomy and the exposure that comes with it. At a club that has already beaten two of the country’s heaviest hitters in the MTN8 this season, holding that standard and making it routine is the mandate.

Immediate horizon: first steps back in Durban

The first weeks will be about clarity and calm more than grand declarations. Arrows do not need reinvention so much as re‑centring: the side that out‑lasted Kaizer Chiefs and Mamelodi Sundowns in the MTN8 exists in this same dressing room. Ncikazi’s task is to tap back into that level while the calendar still offers time to shape the league story.

What will help is the tone set by his former employers. “Mandla leaves with our gratitude and our blessing… We respect his wish,” Khoza said, making the end of one chapter feel crisp and uncomplicated. The rift rumours were dismissed by Ouaddou, the move has been made, and the brief is simple: return Arrows to the habits that defined their unbeaten six, and then push for something higher — the kind of finish that, once before under this coach, felt normal in Durban.

Sources: Ncikazi Lands New PSL Job (idiskitimes.co.za); Khoza Sends Message To Ncikazi (idiskitimes.co.za)
Images: Cover: Football Africa (illustration)
How this article was made: Football Africa uses AI tools to structure, format and optimise its articles, and occasionally to produce illustrated covers where no free photograph exists. The reporting these articles are based on is human-produced and cited above. Spotted an error? Write to [email protected] and we will correct it. — The editors How we work.